Unless you've got a line on purchasing an entire
new style dash you can buy the individual pieces to upgrade just the cubbys & covers. Yes, that'd still leave you with your yellow color tupperware but you'll have the latching right side cubby and matching left side. Check eBay and/or Partzilla.
have a complete right side cubby from a 2010 (the new style) available if anyone is interested.
PS: But if you changed your dash to black shouldn't you also change your floor skirts to black as well. Then a couple of black bands around the tail end would have it looking like a bumblebee