| | Alternative oil Filters for the SW | |
|
| Author | Message |
|---|
keithb Scooter Rider

Number of posts: 30 Points: 433 Registration date: 2011-04-25
 | Subject: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Wed Apr 27, 2011 11:09 am | |
| I hope I am not beating not beating a dead horse here. In anticipatoin of moving to a Silverwing in the future I was checking to see if my oil filter wrench would fit the Fram 6607 filter. Not a chance. Too big. I did find out the Bosch 3300 and the STP 6607 match the Fram filter. BTW, the filter wrench that fits the 6607/3300 filters only costs $5.99 |
|
 | |
DennisB Silver Wing Guru

Number of posts: 2397 Points: 4095 Registration date: 2008-12-28
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Wed Apr 27, 2011 12:03 pm | |
| Hi Keith, We all know that we can use what ever products we want on our scooters but in my observations and study, there are many better filters on the market then FRAM for use on the Silverwing. This subject has been talked about allot on this forum and many others... but use whatever you want but... please do the research. Just my thoughts. |
|
 | |
keithb Scooter Rider

Number of posts: 30 Points: 433 Registration date: 2011-04-25
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Wed Apr 27, 2011 12:18 pm | |
| DennisB No problem. I know the opinions w/Fram oil filters. I use Bosch on my RT and 4Runner. No more oil filter threads from me. |
|
 | |
bigbird Silver Wing Guru


Number of posts: 2164 Location: Winnipeg Canada Points: 3061 Registration date: 2010-05-02
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Wed Apr 27, 2011 12:43 pm | |
| For all the info you want on oil, filters, and much more, try this website:
http://www.bobistheoilguy.com/forums/ubbthreads.php
In the forums section, click on motorcycles and motorcycle lubrication and have at it. |
|
 | |
Old Limey Maxi-Scooter Rider


Number of posts: 171 Age: 67 Location: BOLTON LANCASHIRE ENGLAND Points: 912 Registration date: 2010-06-09
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Thu Apr 28, 2011 3:50 am | |
| Just changed my oil and Filter. In UK the none Honda one seems to be HF204. Got one off ebay for £6.88. Incuding p.p. I always used a chain wrench to remove oil filters, or banged a screw driver through it, if it was the old one. I now have a shiny new wrench i got from Aldi for £3.99. one size fits all as it is adjustable. Worked brilliantly. |
|
 | |
bigbird Silver Wing Guru


Number of posts: 2164 Location: Winnipeg Canada Points: 3061 Registration date: 2010-05-02
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Fri Apr 29, 2011 7:33 am | |
| | Old Limey wrote: | | I always used a chain wrench to remove oil filters, or banged a screw driver through it, if it was the old one. |
Whoever installed the previous oil filter had twisted it on way too tight then. You should be able to remove the old filter by hand if it was installed correctly. I'm assuming one's hands still have prehensile ability that advancing age hasn't stolen yet. |
|
 | |
alejom Scooter Rider


Number of posts: 64 Location: Atlanta, USA Points: 533 Registration date: 2011-02-18
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Fri Apr 29, 2011 8:43 am | |
| I personally stay away from Fram filters; The Honda filter at the dealership cost me less than a Bosch would have cost at the parts store, so I pick that one up.
For a wrench, I use the same wrap-around I use for the family car. It just says "small oil filter wrench" and I think it was not more than 6 dollars. |
|
 | |
john grinsel Silver Wing Expert

Number of posts: 529 Points: 1602 Registration date: 2009-08-18
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Fri Apr 29, 2011 9:43 am | |
| Solution simple----SilverWing uses same filter as Goldwing---WalMart ST6607, works on my NT, too. Priced $3-$4 US.
Nobody here actually rides enough to wear out Honda engine.
Various bikes/scooters WalMart Oil and filters have not failed me in the past 500,000 miles or so. 250 scooters being run wide open most of time (5 of them).
John Grinsel |
|
 | |
WingMan Scooter Rider

Number of posts: 28 Points: 1270 Registration date: 2008-12-26
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Fri Apr 29, 2011 10:18 am | |
| Another oil filter that many Goldwing owners use is the Walmart ST7317, I've used it on my SilverWing for the last three oil changes. |
|
 | |
Old Limey Maxi-Scooter Rider


Number of posts: 171 Age: 67 Location: BOLTON LANCASHIRE ENGLAND Points: 912 Registration date: 2010-06-09
 | Subject: OIl fiters Fri Apr 29, 2011 11:00 am | |
| Bigbird I've never met anyone that could remove an old oil filter by hand. I can just about still crush a grape:x |
|
 | |
model28a Super Scooter Rider


Number of posts: 282 Age: 59 Location: St.Pete.FL. Points: 1135 Registration date: 2010-02-03
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Fri Apr 29, 2011 1:13 pm | |
| I removed my filter by hand last time, then again when I put the filter on I make sure I put oil on the gasket and after it seats I only turn it about 1/2 a turn by hand.I almost never have a problem getting them off. |
|
 | |
bigbird Silver Wing Guru


Number of posts: 2164 Location: Winnipeg Canada Points: 3061 Registration date: 2010-05-02
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Fri Apr 29, 2011 4:08 pm | |
| | Old Limey wrote: | Bigbird I've never met anyone that could remove an old oil filter by hand.
|
Then you've never met me! |
|
 | |
Slick-Tenn Scooter Rider

Number of posts: 47 Points: 732 Registration date: 2010-07-19
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Sun Sep 04, 2011 2:21 pm | |
| | DennisB wrote: | Hi Keith,
We all know that we can use what ever products we want on our scooters but in my observations and study, there are many better filters on the market then FRAM for use on the Silverwing. This subject has been talked about allot on this forum and many others... but use whatever you want but... please do the research.
Just my thoughts. | I, too, did my extensive research and sorry, beg to differ about the Frams. One thing I noticed about all the "testers" who did the "research" was they were amateurs who really knew nothing about what was good or bad. They made their own assumptions based on preconceived notions. One thread I followed actually led to an explanation of why Fram built their filters the way they did - BY A FRAM ENGINEER. His explanation not only was plausible, but made perfect sense. Put simply, the Fram filters are not inferior in any way shape or form. Their Tough Gard filter (TG) filters out as small a micron as anything on the market, contains synthetic media and is guaranteed for 10K. It's about 6 bucks. They're not #1 for nothing. |
|
 | |
Slick-Tenn Scooter Rider

Number of posts: 47 Points: 732 Registration date: 2010-07-19
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Sun Sep 04, 2011 2:31 pm | |
| | keithb wrote: | | I hope I am not beating not beating a dead horse here. In anticipatoin of moving to a Silverwing in the future I was checking to see if my oil filter wrench would fit the Fram 6607 filter. Not a chance. Too big. I did find out the Bosch 3300 and the STP 6607 match the Fram filter. BTW, the filter wrench that fits the 6607/3300 filters only costs $5.99 | The Fram Tough Guard 6607 is made of synthetic media, filters the smallest microns, and works for 10K. Sold! 6 bucks at Advanced Auto Parts. |
|
 | |
Tagg Silver Wing Rider


Number of posts: 439 Points: 1082 Registration date: 2010-11-14
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Mon Sep 05, 2011 7:53 am | |
| | Slick-Tenn wrote: | | DennisB wrote: | Hi Keith,
We all know that we can use what ever products we want on our scooters but in my observations and study, there are many better filters on the market then FRAM for use on the Silverwing. This subject has been talked about allot on this forum and many others... but use whatever you want but... please do the research.
Just my thoughts. | I, too, did my extensive research and sorry, beg to differ about the Frams. One thing I noticed about all the "testers" who did the "research" was they were amateurs who really knew nothing about what was good or bad. They made their own assumptions based on preconceived notions. One thread I followed actually led to an explanation of why Fram built their filters the way they did - BY A FRAM ENGINEER. His explanation not only was plausible, but made perfect sense. Put simply, the Fram filters are not inferior in any way shape or form. Their Tough Gard filter (TG) filters out as small a micron as anything on the market, contains synthetic media and is guaranteed for 10K. It's about 6 bucks. They're not #1 for nothing. |
A Fram engineer saying his filter is as good as anyones? Of course it sounds plausible, and makes perfect sense. Did you really think he would say anything else? Use your brain. i will always trust a 3rd party engineering report before a oem manufacturer, be it filters or anything else. But then again, ive never been lied to by a corporation that has a vested interest before. |
|
 | |
Tagg Silver Wing Rider


Number of posts: 439 Points: 1082 Registration date: 2010-11-14
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Mon Sep 05, 2011 8:04 am | |
| Having said that, and to soften it a bit, i have no recollection of any motor having failed due to any oil filter, or its life being somehow measurably shortened by one.
I believe that somewhere out there in the myriad of articles and charts, and personal qualifications, there is a "best" oil filter somewhere, i also believe that the oil its self, and its condition, is more of a contributing factor to engine performance and durability. |
|
 | |
Slick-Tenn Scooter Rider

Number of posts: 47 Points: 732 Registration date: 2010-07-19
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Thu Sep 08, 2011 4:07 pm | |
| | Tagg wrote: | | Slick-Tenn wrote: | | DennisB wrote: | Hi Keith,
We all know that we can use what ever products we want on our scooters but in my observations and study, there are many better filters on the market then FRAM for use on the Silverwing. This subject has been talked about allot on this forum and many others... but use whatever you want but... please do the research.
Just my thoughts. | I, too, did my extensive research and sorry, beg to differ about the Frams. One thing I noticed about all the "testers" who did the "research" was they were amateurs who really knew nothing about what was good or bad. They made their own assumptions based on preconceived notions. One thread I followed actually led to an explanation of why Fram built their filters the way they did - BY A FRAM ENGINEER. His explanation not only was plausible, but made perfect sense. Put simply, the Fram filters are not inferior in any way shape or form. Their Tough Gard filter (TG) filters out as small a micron as anything on the market, contains synthetic media and is guaranteed for 10K. It's about 6 bucks. They're not #1 for nothing. |
A Fram engineer saying his filter is as good as anyones? Of course it sounds plausible, and makes perfect sense. Did you really think he would say anything else? Use your brain. i will always trust a 3rd party engineering report before a oem manufacturer, be it filters or anything else. But then again, ive never been lied to by a corporation that has a vested interest before. | Ouch! First of all, "third party?" All of the "third parties" I saw were non-engineer-types - regular guys like you and me. Please tell me, how is they know what's good and what's bad in designing and building an oil filter? I'm not a country bumpkin, my friend. When I said the Fram engineer's explanation made perfect sense, I mean I understand bullshit when I hear it. Your friend next door saws a Fram filter in two and proclaims "it doesn't have a steel frame. Therefore, it's not a good filter and is unacceptable." Now THAT is bullshit my friend! |
|
 | |
bigbird Silver Wing Guru


Number of posts: 2164 Location: Winnipeg Canada Points: 3061 Registration date: 2010-05-02
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Thu Sep 08, 2011 4:08 pm | |
| Slick-Tenn: I don't think Tagg is your friend. |
|
 | |
Slick-Tenn Scooter Rider

Number of posts: 47 Points: 732 Registration date: 2010-07-19
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Fri Sep 09, 2011 6:03 pm | |
| | bigbird wrote: | | Slick-Tenn: I don't think Tagg is your friend. | I'm not looking for friends, but it really does irritate me when people simply accept what they're reading simply because it's in writing. Regarding the dissing of Fram filters, there have been ONLY laymen wade in on the subject - using their own (uneducated) opinions. Fram is the #1 automotive filter maker for a good reason: They make reasonably-priced, quality oil filters. Period. And listen, I'm not a brand loyalist! I've used other filters and they're (mostly) all good. Personally, I think today, the Mobil 1 Oil filter is the best quality filter on the market, but it's expensive. The Fram does ALMOST as good a job for about half the cost. Yes, the Walmart filters are excellent quality too (manufactured by Champion Filters - not the spark plug folks), but do not mention their effectiveness at filtering (Fram is 97-99%). |
|
 | |
wingmann Scooter Rider


Number of posts: 36 Age: 55 Location: HAM lake MN. USA Points: 699 Registration date: 2010-08-22
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Fri Sep 09, 2011 6:59 pm | |
| Has anyone checked the consumer report Mag or web site to see the oil filter tests that thay did. Maybe someone on this forum can find the mag that has the oil filter tests or maybe someone has a paid mebership to the consumer report web site. The test that thay did should tell us the filter that filters the oil the best. |
|
 | |
"Hi Yo" Silver Wing Expert


Number of posts: 860 Age: 63 Location: North Texas Points: 1834 Registration date: 2010-02-17
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Fri Sep 09, 2011 7:17 pm | |
| We don't need no stinking reports! We got Grinsel! |
|
 | |
bigbird Silver Wing Guru


Number of posts: 2164 Location: Winnipeg Canada Points: 3061 Registration date: 2010-05-02
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Fri Sep 09, 2011 7:36 pm | |
| | Slick-Tenn wrote: | | bigbird wrote: | | Slick-Tenn: I don't think Tagg is your friend. | I'm not looking for friends, |
You did call Tagg your "friend", twice in fact. You never called me your "friend". |
|
 | |
Tagg Silver Wing Rider


Number of posts: 439 Points: 1082 Registration date: 2010-11-14
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Fri Sep 09, 2011 10:34 pm | |
| | Slick-Tenn wrote: | | Tagg wrote: | | Slick-Tenn wrote: | | DennisB wrote: | Hi Keith,
We all know that we can use what ever products we want on our scooters but in my observations and study, there are many better filters on the market then FRAM for use on the Silverwing. This subject has been talked about allot on this forum and many others... but use whatever you want but... please do the research.
Just my thoughts. | I, too, did my extensive research and sorry, beg to differ about the Frams. One thing I noticed about all the "testers" who did the "research" was they were amateurs who really knew nothing about what was good or bad. They made their own assumptions based on preconceived notions. One thread I followed actually led to an explanation of why Fram built their filters the way they did - BY A FRAM ENGINEER. His explanation not only was plausible, but made perfect sense. Put simply, the Fram filters are not inferior in any way shape or form. Their Tough Gard filter (TG) filters out as small a micron as anything on the market, contains synthetic media and is guaranteed for 10K. It's about 6 bucks. They're not #1 for nothing. |
A Fram engineer saying his filter is as good as anyones? Of course it sounds plausible, and makes perfect sense. Did you really think he would say anything else? Use your brain. i will always trust a 3rd party engineering report before a oem manufacturer, be it filters or anything else. But then again, ive never been lied to by a corporation that has a vested interest before. | Ouch! First of all, "third party?" All of the "third parties" I saw were non-engineer-types - regular guys like you and me. Please tell me, how is they know what's good and what's bad in designing and building an oil filter? I'm not a country bumpkin, my friend. When I said the Fram engineer's explanation made perfect sense, I mean I understand bull**** when I hear it. Your friend next door saws a Fram filter in two and proclaims "it doesn't have a steel frame. Therefore, it's not a good filter and is unacceptable." Now THAT is bull**** my friend! |
A wonderful example of only seeing what you want to see yes? THIRD PARTY ENGINEERING REPORT. Pay attention next time. there's a huge difference between an organized empirical engineering report, and a guy with a bandsaw, Apparently we both see that dont we? I wont apologize cause you got a little butt-hurt,but i mean what i say, you'll get over it.

Last edited by Tagg on Fri Sep 09, 2011 10:40 pm; edited 1 time in total |
|
 | |
Tagg Silver Wing Rider


Number of posts: 439 Points: 1082 Registration date: 2010-11-14
 | Subject: Re: Alternative oil Filters for the SW Fri Sep 09, 2011 10:36 pm | |
| | "Hi Yo" wrote: | We don't need no stinking reports! We got Grinsel! |
Ha Ha! you mean obi-john! |
|
 | |
| | Alternative oil Filters for the SW | |
|